A loyalty program can be one of the most effective tools a café or restaurant has. Or it can be a needlessly complex system that customers ignore and staff hate.

The difference is in the setup. This guide shows you how to design a program that works.

Step 1: How to choose the right reward model?

There are three basic loyalty program models. Each suits a different type of venue.

Stamp card

The simplest model. The customer collects stamps for each visit or purchase and, once they reach a set number, gets a reward.

Suitable for: cafés, bakeries, quick-service food, barbershops Example: 10 stamps = a free coffee

The advantage is complete simplicity; the customer immediately understands what they get and how. The downside is lower flexibility (you can’t easily target different rewards to different customers).

Points system

The customer collects points for their spend (for example 1 point for every €0.40) and exchanges points for discounts or products.

Suitable for: restaurants, wine shops, specialty stores Example: 100 points = €2 off your next purchase

The advantage is flexibility and the option to segment. The downside is greater complexity; the customer has to understand what the points mean.

Membership program

The customer pays a fee or registers as a member and gets ongoing benefits (discounts, priority, exclusive offers).

Suitable for: fitness, premium restaurants, specialty shops Example: Membership for €8/month = 15% off everything

For cafés and restaurants, the best choice is a stamp card or a points system. Start with the simpler model; you can always add complexity, but taking it away is harder.

Step 2: How to set a reward that works?

The reward has to be attractive but also economically sustainable.

The golden rule: the reward should have a perceived value to the customer that is higher than its actual cost to you.

A free coffee after 10 coffees costs you roughly €0.60 to €1 (ingredient cost), but the customer perceives it as worth €2.50 to €3.30. The ratio is excellent.

What works as a reward:

  • A free product (most popular)
  • A discount on the next purchase
  • An upgrade (a larger coffee, a dessert with a meal)
  • Exclusive access (a tasting, member-only events)

What doesn’t work:

  • Rewards that are too far off (20+ stamps for the first reward)
  • Complex conditions and exceptions
  • Rewards with low perceived value

Step 3: Which technology to choose?

Paper cards are outdated, but you don’t need to build your own app right away.

A Wallet card is today’s best compromise between simplicity for the customer and features for the venue:

  • The customer always has it on hand (in the phone)
  • Staff add a stamp with a single tap
  • The venue can send push notifications
  • The system collects data on footfall
  • No app installation on the customer’s side

Compared to paper cards, you also gain insight into how many customers actively use the program, how often they come, and when they last visited the venue.

Step 4: How to train the staff?

The biggest reason loyalty programs fail is not the technology; it’s staff who only offer the card to every third customer.

Set up a simple script:

“Do you have our loyalty card? Just scan the QR code and the card saves to your phone; next time we’ll add the stamp in a few seconds.”

Staff have to offer the program actively, not wait for the customer to ask. The goal is to add the card for every new customer on their first or second visit.

Step 5: How to promote the program properly?

Customers who don’t know about the program can’t use it.

Offline: a QR code on the counter, on the table, on the receipt, on the window Online: Instagram stories, a post at launch, a link in your Google Business profile In person: staff actively offer it with every payment

It also helps to tell customers a concrete benefit: “Collect stamps and your 10th coffee is on us.” Not an abstract “Join the loyalty program.”

What to expect after launch?

First month: collecting data, customers register, staff get used to the new process Second month: the first customers redeem rewards, activity grows Third month: a measurable increase in repeat visits, the first reactivation campaigns

A loyalty program is not a sprint; it’s a marathon. But venues that set it up right and stick with it consistently see measurable results within 90 days.

More useful resources

External sources

Want to launch a loyalty program via Wallet in a few minutes? Get in touch and we’ll sort out the details.